Tiling is among the most-disputed handover items in Australian new builds. Defects are usually visible in some form, but homeowners often do not recognise them until after acceptance, when rectification becomes more difficult and more expensive. This guide walks through the defect categories that show up repeatedly (lippage, hollow tiles, grout failures, wet area issues, substrate problems), how to inspect for each at pre-handover, and what to do when you find them. AS 3958:2023, Installation of ceramic and stone tiles, incorporating Amendment No. 1 (June 2024), provides tiling installation requirements and guidance. AS 3740:2021 addresses domestic wet-area waterproofing. Apply the editions and provisions required by the project’s adopted NCC, approval, contract and specification; a standard is not automatically mandatory merely because it exists.
Why tiling defects matter in new builds
Tiling consistently shows up at the top of the dispute list at practical completion, alongside paint and cabinetry. The reasons are structural rather than incidental. Tiling is a highly skilled trade with significant variation in competency between operators. It coordinates with multiple other trades (waterproofers, plumbers, carpenters, plasterers) and the quality of any one of those upstream trades affects the tile result. It is typically the last wet trade on the build and often runs into time pressure as the builder pushes toward handover. And because tile and grout are the visible final surface, every defect upstream eventually shows.
The cost of getting tiling wrong is concentrated and visible. A failed shower floor means stripping tiles, re-doing waterproofing and re-laying. Lippage on a kitchen splashback at eye level cannot be polished out. Tiles with verified inadequate bond may crack or release and require selective rectification that rarely matches the surrounding work. The rectification cost on a meaningfully defective bathroom typically runs to several thousand dollars and several weeks of disruption, which is why builders sometimes resist conceding the defect at handover.
Tiles and grout are not a substitute for the specified waterproofing system. Hollow sounds alone do not prove failed waterproofing.
AS 3958:2023, Installation of ceramic and stone tiles, incorporating Amendment No. 1 (June 2024), provides tiling installation requirements and guidance. AS 3740:2021 addresses domestic wet-area waterproofing. Apply the editions and provisions required by the project’s adopted NCC, approval, contract and specification; a standard is not automatically mandatory merely because it exists. Related guidance: what a tiler does in residential construction and defects after handover and how to handle building disputes.
Lippage: the most common visible defect
Lippage is the vertical height difference between the edges of adjacent tiles. It is the most common visible tiling defect and the one most homeowners notice first, particularly on floors where the eye picks up height differences in oblique light. Lippage matters because it affects appearance, creates trip hazards in walkways, traps water in wet areas, and signals deeper installation issues even where the lippage itself is within tolerance.
Assess lippage using the applicable standard clause, tile properties including warpage, joint arrangement and specified finish. Do not infer that larger tiles automatically permit more lippage. Ask for the exact clause and applicable edition before accepting a numerical limit.
Causes of lippage trace back through the install process. Uneven substrate is the most common root cause: tiles laid over a substrate with high spots and low spots will inherit those height variations regardless of tiler skill. Inadequate substrate preparation (failure to grind down high spots, fill low spots, or apply a self-levelling compound where required) is the upstream version of the same issue. Inadequate adhesive application, wrong adhesive for the substrate or tile type, inadequate spacers, and rushed installation all contribute. Manufactured warpage on the tiles themselves can produce lippage even on a perfect substrate, particularly with larger format porcelain.
Lippage shows up most visibly on floor tiles in oblique daylight, on splashbacks at eye level, and in wet area floors where it compounds water management problems. Around penetrations (drain edges, fixture cuts) lippage tends to concentrate because the tiler is working in a more constrained space.
Inspecting for lippage at handover is straightforward but takes time. Raking light can help locate concerns but formal appearance assessment should use the applicable viewing conditions. Record measured differences and locations. Run the back of your hand across the tile surface; lippage is felt as raised edges before it is seen. Look for uneven grout lines, which indicate uneven tile heights. Photograph any lippage with the camera at floor level, with a coin or other reference object adjacent for scale, and note the location precisely. Pay particular attention to wet area floors, splashbacks at eye level, and high-traffic floors where the trip-hazard implication is most direct. See construction tolerances in Australia and final inspection checklist before handover.
Hollow tiles: the hidden defect
Hollow-sounding tiles are a screening observation, not proof of inadequate bond. Sounds can vary with the installation system and substrate. An appropriately qualified inspector should investigate concerns against the applicable criteria. Understand the limits of evaluating waterproofing in a completed project before relying on visible tile finishes. Follow a consistent process to document defects for disputes and claims, including dated photographs and inspection records.
Hollow tiles arise from a few related causes. Inadequate adhesive coverage (skim coating the substrate, dot-and-dab application, or failing to back-butter larger tiles) leaves voids. Adhesive setting before the tile is placed produces poor wet-set bond, particularly in hot conditions or where the tiler is working too far ahead. Wrong adhesive for the substrate (cement-based on a flexible substrate, or interior adhesive in a wet area) reduces bond strength. Movement or expansion stress can break a marginal bond after installation. Substrate problems (dust, contamination, inadequate primer) prevent the adhesive from gripping. The common thread is corner-cutting at the install stage, often under time pressure.
Adhesive coverage and bond requirements depend on the applicable installation system and standard provisions. Tap sounds do not measure coverage and there is no universal acceptable percentage of hollow-sounding tiles stated here.
Gentle tapping may help locate changes in sound but neither a solid nor hollow sound establishes bond adequacy or waterproofing performance. Record locations and arrange qualified assessment; do not treat tap testing as proof of a defect.
Critical locations include wet area floors (where the hollow void compromises water management above the waterproofing membrane), bathroom walls, kitchen splashbacks, pool surrounds and external tiling. In each of these the consequence of progressive failure is concentrated; in lower-traffic dry areas the consequence is mostly cosmetic. Hollow tiles in critical areas warrant rectification before sign-off; hollow tiles in lower-priority dry areas can reasonably go on the defects list. See waterproofing and common plumbing issues in new builds.
Grout failures and joint defects
Grout is the visible interface between tiles and the first place defects in the surrounding installation tend to show. Cracking, discolouration, missing grout, wrong grout type and inadequate movement joints are the patterns that recur across new builds.
Grout cracking can indicate movement, joint design or product issues. Cracks should be recorded and investigated rather than assumed to resolve through settlement. Corner cracking does not alone prove one particular cause.
Grout discolouration can have several causes including moisture, cleaning, mixing and curing. It does not alone prove hollow tiles or membrane failure. Investigate persistent dampness or mould alongside ventilation, drainage and installation records.
Missing or incomplete grout (voids in joints, joints not packed to the tile surface, gaps at corners) is a finishing failure that allows water and dirt ingress and accelerates grout breakdown. Wrong grout type for the application is more subtle: sanded grout in narrow joints does not pack properly and looks rough; unsanded grout in wide joints cracks and shrinks; the wrong waterproof rating in a wet area accelerates failure. Wrong grout colour is a specification rather than installation issue but is worth catching at handover.
Use the designed movement-joint system and compatible sealant where specified. Do not rigidly grout joints intended to accommodate movement. Product selection depends on joint geometry, expected movement and exposure rather than a silicone-only rule.
Inspecting grout at handover is mostly visual but worth doing systematically. Walk every grout line in good lighting. Press a fingernail into the grout at several locations; properly cured grout is firm. Check colour consistency across each room and between rooms tiled at the same time. Verify movement joints against the designed system and compatible sealant specification rather than assuming silicone is always required. Inspect corner joints particularly carefully; they are where movement and water ingress concentrate. See common painting defects in new builds for the parallel finishing-trade pattern.
Wet area defects: where tiling and waterproofing meet
AS 3740:2021 addresses domestic wet-area waterproofing within its scope. External balconies and pool surrounds require the provisions relevant to those applications. AS 3958:2023 incorporating Amendment No. 1 (June 2024) addresses tile installation. Apply the project’s adopted NCC, approval and contract requirements.
Falls to waste are the most consequential geometric detail in a wet area. The floor should slope consistently toward the floor waste so that water flows to drain rather than pooling on the tile surface. AS 3740 sets out the minimum fall requirement; verify the specifics with the standard rather than relying on industry rules of thumb. Inadequate falls cause water pooling, which over time leads to grout breakdown, mould, slip hazards and waterproofing compromise. Reversed falls (water flowing away from the floor waste) are a more serious defect requiring re-laying tiles, not patching grout. Check falls with a tape measure and a small spirit level; pour a small volume of water near the wall and observe whether it flows to the waste.
Penetrations and wastes need compatible watertight details in accordance with the applicable waterproofing design and product system. A membrane-to-waste flange is not necessarily visible at the finished tile surface. Neat tile cuts do not by themselves prove the concealed waterproofing detail.
Waterproofing extent, wall heights, laps, corners and reinforcement depend on the wet-area location, substrate and specified system. Verify the applicable AS 3740:2021 provisions and approved details rather than applying a universal 150mm wall height. Construction records help assess concealed work.
Tiles and grout are not a substitute for the specified waterproofing system. Hollow sounds or grout discolouration do not alone establish membrane failure. Investigate water retention, movement and any installation damage using the actual system details.
Junction details (wall-to-floor, corner-to-corner, door thresholds, pool surround interfaces) are where waterproofing and tiling come together most visibly. Use the designed movement-joint system and compatible sealant where specified; do not rigidly grout a designed movement joint. Door thresholds should hold water inside the wet zone with a hob, sill or graded transition. The shower door track and hinge fixings should not penetrate the waterproofing membrane in ways that compromise it. See waterproofing and what a waterproofer does.
Substrate and preparation defects
Tiling is only as good as the substrate it sits on. Many of the defects visible at handover originate not in the tiling work itself but in the substrate preparation that preceded it. Concrete that has not properly cured, plaster that has not been sanded flat, sheet substrates with unsealed joints, and dust or contamination on the surface all compromise the tile installation regardless of tiler skill.
Common substrate issues include uneven floor levels with high spots and low spots, substrate cracks not repaired before tiling, sheet substrates fixed without joint sealing, concrete laid too recently to be tile-ready, and the wrong substrate material for the application (chipboard in a wet area, for example). Each of these surfaces as a different defect on the tile: uneven substrate produces lippage; substrate cracks produce tile cracks; unsealed joints produce grout failure along the joint line; insufficiently cured concrete produces ongoing movement that breaks adhesive bond.
Preparation defects include inadequate dust removal before adhesive application, missing or inadequate primer, failure to flatten high spots or fill low spots, and proceeding with installation when site conditions (temperature, humidity, recent water exposure) are outside the adhesive manufacturer's specification. The tiler often inherits these issues from upstream trades and is then in the position of either proceeding and accepting the defect risk, or holding up the program until the substrate is corrected. Time pressure usually pushes the decision toward proceeding.
What homeowners can verify at handover is limited because the substrate is hidden. Walk floors and listen for flexing, cracking or hollow sounds underfoot, particularly around the edges of rooms. Verify walls are level and plumb where they meet floors, ceilings and door frames. Look for movement at junctions where tiles meet other materials. None of this is conclusive but each is a signal worth following up.
Documentation captured during the build is the only reliable way to verify substrate preparation after the tiles are on. Photographs of the substrate before primer, after primer, and before tiling are standard quality-assurance practice for builders who take this seriously. Where the documentation does not exist, the homeowner has limited recourse if substrate-driven defects emerge later. Asking for the substrate documentation at handover is reasonable and the response is informative either way. See construction tolerances in Australia for the broader pattern.
How to inspect tiling at pre-handover
A systematic inspection takes longer than a casual walk-through but produces a defect list the builder can engage with rather than dismiss. Plan for at least an hour per wet area on a typical home, more for larger or more complex builds.
Equipment is modest. Good lighting matters most: daylight where possible, supplemented by a strong portable light held at low angles to surface lippage and surface defects. A camera or phone for documentation, with the timestamp and location of each photograph noted. A small spirit level for falls and alignment checks. A tape measure for falls and movement joint dimensions. A small hard object (a coin works well) for the tap test on hollow tiles. A notepad or a structured photo-with-notes app for documenting defects in a way that survives the handover meeting.
Inspect room by room rather than defect category by defect category, so that nothing is missed in any one space. In each wet area, work through visual lippage check (multiple angles, multiple lighting conditions), the tap test on every floor tile and a representative sample of wall tiles, falls to waste check (visual flow plus tape measure plus small water pour), penetration detail inspection at each tap, drain, basin and toilet, grout consistency and colour across the room, movement joint inspection (silicone present, correct colour, correct product), edge sealant at junctions with other materials, and verification that waterproofing flanges are visible at floor wastes.
In the kitchen, work through splashback lippage at eye level, the counter-meeting-splashback junction (usually silicone, check colour and product), tile cuts around outlets and switches, tile cuts around taps and other fixtures, and movement joints at room boundaries. In tiled living areas or hallways, work through visual lippage from low angles, movement joint placement at room boundaries and at the perimeter of large tiled areas, pattern alignment if a directional or matched pattern was specified, and tile cuts at room boundaries and door thresholds.
Document every defect as you find it. Photograph with adequate lighting and a reference object for scale. Note the precise location (which room, which wall or floor area, near which fixture). Note the size of the defect (lippage measured in millimetres, hollow tile area, grout failure length). Note the category (lippage, hollow, grout, waterproofing, substrate). Issue the complete defect list to the builder in writing before the handover meeting; arriving at the meeting with a documented list shifts the conversation from negotiation to rectification scope.
Where defects are extensive, the builder is dismissive, or the pre-handover sign-off is otherwise complicated, an independent building inspector can be engaged for a one-off inspection. The inspector's report carries more weight than homeowner observation and is useful both for the immediate handover negotiation and for any subsequent dispute or warranty claim. The cost of an independent inspection is typically a few hundred dollars; the cost of accepting handover with significant unrectified defects is much higher. See final inspection checklist before handover, how to handle building disputes and how to document defects, disputes and claims.
Red flags when reviewing tiling work
Tiling defects rarely sit in isolation. Where one of the patterns below shows up, others are usually present and worth looking for. The list below covers the signals that recur across handover inspections.
Warning signs
- Builder rushing the tiling inspection or limiting time for review. Proper tiling inspection takes substantial time, particularly in wet areas where multiple defect categories interact. A builder rushing the homeowner through the inspection or pushing back on the time required is a signal that the work may not stand up to scrutiny.
- Visible lippage at multiple locations beyond AS 3958 tolerance. Isolated lippage can occur on any job. Lippage visible at multiple locations across multiple rooms indicates a systemic installation issue rather than an isolated incident, and usually means the substrate preparation or the installation discipline has slipped.
- Changes in tile sound needing investigation. Record the affected locations and use the assessment process in the hollow tiles section before agreeing on repairs.
- Falls to waste inadequate, missing or running the wrong way. Wet area floors should slope toward the floor waste consistently. Inadequate falls cause water pooling, which over time leads to grout failure, mould growth and waterproofing compromise. Reversed falls (water flowing away from the waste) require re-laying tiles, not patching grout.
- Penetration details rough, chipped or visibly compromised. Tile cuts around taps, drains, basins and toilet penetrations should be clean and waterproofing-to-waste details need verification from the design and construction records, not an assumed visible flange. Rough penetrations are a water ingress risk and a sign of inadequate care or skill at the most critical points.
- Designed movement joints missing or rigidly grouted. Movement joints accommodate substrate and tile expansion. Rigid grout can prevent designed movement and contribute to cracking. Use the designed joint system and compatible sealant where specified. Wall-to-floor and corner-to-corner junctions are the most common locations.
- Wrong grout type for the joint width or application. Sanded grout in narrow joints looks rough and does not pack properly; unsanded grout in wide joints cracks and shrinks. The wrong waterproof rating in a wet area accelerates grout failure. The grout specification should match the joint width and the application.
- Builder dismissing visible defects as 'settle in' or 'normal'. AS 3958 tolerances define what is acceptable. Defects outside tolerance are not normal and do not settle in. Where a builder reframes a tolerance issue as cosmetic or expected, ask for the specific tolerance reference; the answer should be substantive rather than dismissive.
- No documentation of substrate preparation or waterproofing inspection. Substrate flatness, primer application, waterproofing membrane installation and waterproofing inspection records all sit behind the tiles and cannot be verified at handover. Documentation captured during the build is the only way to verify the work, and undermines warranty claims if absent.
- Tile cuts visibly amateur (chipped edges, uneven cuts, misaligned). Cuts around outlets, switches, taps and room boundaries are where tiler skill shows most clearly. Chipped, uneven or misaligned cuts signal inadequate skill or time pressure, and usually correlate with other quality issues elsewhere in the work.
- Grout colour visibly inconsistent between batches or rooms. Grout mixed in multiple batches without colour discipline produces visibly different shades across a floor or between rooms. The defect is cosmetic but indicates rushed work or inadequate quality control, and is hard to rectify without re-grouting the affected area.
- External or pool surround tiles not specified for external use. External tiles and pool surrounds need products rated for frost, UV and wet-dry cycling. Internal-grade tiles installed externally typically fail within a few seasons through frost spalling, UV degradation or grout failure. Verify the product specification matches the application before sign-off.
For the broader pattern of trade selection and verification, see red flags when choosing a builder and how to vet a builder.
BUILTLY and tiler verification
BUILTLY is building a record of completed Australian homes that credits the builder and specialist trades behind each one.
For tiling that means a builder profile carries a documented track record of completed wet area work, tiler profiles surface their relevant experience and the projects they have delivered, the waterproofer who worked alongside them on each project is visible, and past projects show evidence of the work delivered together rather than in isolation. For homeowners, that turns tiler selection from a phone-call-and-hope exercise into a record-led decision, which matters more on tiling than most because the cost of getting it wrong is concentrated and visible.
BUILTLY is heading toward a 2026 launch. Until then, the guide library, including the complete guide to building a house in Australia, is the active value: a careful reference for anyone navigating a new build right now.
Frequently asked questions
Can I refuse to accept handover if tiling defects are significant?
Whether defects prevent practical completion depends on the contract and applicable law. Minor defects can remain on an agreed list; significant safety, use or waterproofing concerns need prompt professional advice. Record defects with photographs and locations and request a written response and rectification timetable. Do not withhold payment or refuse handover solely on this guide.
What is the warranty period for tiling work in Australia?
Tiling falls under the builder's statutory warranty for the home, which varies by state but is typically six to seven years for major defects and shorter for non-structural defects. The exact warranty period and what counts as structural versus non-structural is set by state legislation and the building contract. Tile and grout suppliers also offer manufacturer warranties on the products themselves, separate from the installation warranty. Workmanship issues (lippage, hollow tiles, grout failures, falls to waste) sit with the builder under the building contract; product failures (tile cracking from manufacturing defect, grout discolouration from a bad batch) sit with the supplier. Verify your specific warranty position with your contract and your state's building authority.
Can hollow tiles be fixed without complete re-tiling?
A hollow sound alone does not establish a defect or determine rectification scope. Have an appropriately qualified inspector assess the installation system, bond and applicable criteria. If defective tiles need removal, the repair must address the cause and protect or reinstate any affected waterproofing. Obtain the proposed scope in writing.
Is the tiler or the builder responsible for tiling defects?
The builder is responsible to the homeowner under the building contract, regardless of whether the tiling was performed by the builder's own employees or by a subcontracted tiler. The internal arrangement between builder and tiler is the builder's problem, not the homeowner's. This matters in practice because some builders try to direct homeowners to deal with the tiler directly when defects emerge, which is not how the contract works. Defects should be raised with the builder, documented in writing, and rectified by the builder under the warranty. Where the tiler is no longer engaged, the builder remains responsible for the work.
How much rectification is reasonable to expect before handover?
Ask for a written rectification scope and timetable that addresses the cause, any affected waterproofing and matching finishes. For the contract and payment caveat, see the handover FAQ above.