Choosing a builder for a renovation is a meaningfully different process to choosing a builder for a new home. Renovation builders work within existing structures, in occupied homes, around hidden services and with conditions that cannot be fully known until the walls are opened. The wrong builder on a renovation can cost you more in variations, delays and rectification than the renovation itself. This guide covers what to look for, what to ask, what the contract should include and how to avoid the most common mistakes Australian renovators make when selecting a builder.
Why a renovation builder is different to a new build builder
| Renovation builder | New build builder | |
|---|---|---|
| Works within | Existing structure, occupied home | Clean site, blank canvas |
| Hidden conditions | Structural surprises, services, asbestos common | Site conditions known before contract |
| Contract type | Usually shorter, staged or fixed price by scope | Full building contract, progress payments |
| Trade coordination | Tight sequencing in confined spaces | Broader site and longer timeline |
| Council approvals | Required for structural changes, extensions | Full DA and building permit process |
| Communication | Daily contact more common in occupied homes | Weekly site visits typical |
| Licence requirement | Builder's licence required - class varies by state | Builder's licence required |
Not all builders who excel at new homes are experienced renovation builders. Renovating requires a specific skill set - the ability to work around existing structures without unnecessary damage, to sequence trades correctly in tight spaces, to identify and manage unknown conditions as they emerge, and to communicate daily with homeowners who are living in the home while work is underway. Always ask specifically about renovation experience before engaging a builder for any project that is not a new build. For a complete due diligence framework refer to the BUILTLY guide on how to vet a builder in Australia.
Step one - define your scope before approaching builders
The most common mistake Australian renovators make is approaching builders for quotes before they have a clear and documented scope of works. Without a detailed scope, builders cannot quote accurately and you cannot compare quotes meaningfully. What looks like a $40,000 renovation from one builder and $65,000 from another is often simply two different assumptions about what is included.
Before approaching any builder, prepare the following:
- Architectural plans or a detailed brief if structural changes are involved
- A written list of every room or area being renovated and what work is required in each
- Fixture and fitting selections or allowances - kitchen, bathroom, flooring, joinery
- Any council approvals already obtained or an understanding of whether approvals are required
- Your budget range and timeline
The more specific you are at the quoting stage, the more accurate and comparable the quotes you receive will be. A good renovation builder will tell you upfront if your scope exceeds your stated budget - a poor one will underquote to win the job and recover the margin through variations. Be mindful of overcapitalising - spending more on the renovation than the value it adds to your property.
Licence and insurance - the non-negotiables
Builder's licence
All renovation builders in Australia must hold a current builder's licence for the state in which they are working. Licence classes and requirements vary by state. Verify the licence directly with the licensing authority - do not rely on what a builder tells you or a printed licence number on a quote. Licences can be suspended or cancelled without the holder removing them from their marketing materials.
- Queensland - QBCC licence. For renovations over $3,300, a builder's licence is required
- New South Wales - Contractor licence under the Home Building Act. Required for all residential building work over $5,000
- Victoria - Registered builder under the Building and Plumbing Commission (BPC)
- Western Australia - Registered builder with the Building Services Board
- South Australia, Tasmania, ACT, Northern Territory - Check the relevant state building authority for current requirements
Insurance
At a minimum, a renovation builder must carry:
- Public liability insurance - minimum $5 million is standard
- Workers compensation insurance covering all workers on site
- Contract works insurance covering the building works against damage or loss during construction
For home building work above the statutory threshold in your state, builders must also provide home warranty insurance (also called home building compensation insurance) before commencing work. This protects you if the builder becomes insolvent, dies or disappears before completing the work. Confirm home warranty insurance has been issued before any work commences.
How to find renovation builders
Referrals from people you trust
Personal referrals from friends, family or neighbours who have recently completed a renovation are the most reliable source of renovation builder recommendations. Ask specifically: would you use them again and was the final cost close to the quoted cost.
Industry associations
Master Builders Australia and the Housing Industry Association both maintain directories of member builders. Membership is not a guarantee of quality but indicates a level of professional standing and access to industry-standard contracts.
Previous project verification
For larger renovations, ask to see completed projects - not just photos but actual addresses you can visit and inspect. Speaking directly with previous clients about communication, variations, timeline and final cost is more valuable than any portfolio or website. Be aware that online reviews alone are not a reliable indicator of renovation capability.
What to avoid
BUILTLY is building a record of completed Australian homes that credits the builder, designers and trades behind each one.
How to compare renovation quotes
Getting at least three quotes for any renovation over $20,000 is standard practice. Comparing renovation quotes requires understanding what is and is not included in each one.
A properly itemised renovation quote should include:
- A detailed scope of works covering every area of the renovation
- Specific inclusions - materials, fixtures, finishes and brands where relevant
- Provisional sums or prime cost items where selections have not been finalised - with clear allowance amounts
- A clear statement of what is excluded
- A timeline with key milestones
- Payment schedule tied to progress milestones or stages
When comparing quotes, align each quote item by item against your scope. A quote that is $15,000 lower than the others may have excluded waterproofing, electrical upgrades, plastering or disposal of waste - all costs that will reappear as variations once work commences.
Ask every builder to itemise their variations policy. How are variations priced? What approval process is required before variation work proceeds? Uncontrolled variations are the primary cause of renovation cost blowouts.
Questions to ask a renovation builder before signing
- How many renovations similar to mine have you completed in the past two years? Can I contact previous clients?
- Will you personally manage this project or will a site supervisor be responsible day to day? Who is my main contact?
- How do you manage unexpected conditions - for example, if asbestos is found or a structural element is not as shown on the plans?
- What is your variations process and how are variations priced?
- What is your payment schedule and what does each progress payment correspond to?
- What contract will we use? Is it an HIA or Master Builders standard contract?
- What is your expected timeline and what are the key milestones?
- Do you use licensed subcontractors for all trades? Can I see their licences?
- How will you manage site access, noise and disruption if I am living in the home during the renovation?
- What happens if you discover the renovation will cost more than quoted?
- Do you carry home warranty insurance and will you provide the certificate before commencing?
Understanding the renovation contract
A written building contract is legally required for most residential building work in Australia above the statutory threshold in your state. For renovation work, the contract should be reviewed carefully before signing.
What the contract must include
- Full scope of works in detail - not a summary
- All materials, fixtures and finishes specified or with clear provisional sum allowances
- Start date and anticipated completion date
- Payment schedule tied to completion of defined stages - not calendar dates
- A clear variations clause specifying how additional work is approved and priced
- Dispute resolution process
- Builder's licence number and insurance details
- Home warranty insurance details where applicable
Provisional sums and prime cost items
Renovation contracts frequently include provisional sums (PS) and prime cost (PC) items where final selections or costs cannot be determined at contract signing. These are allowances - not fixed prices. If the actual cost exceeds the allowance, you pay the difference.
Always review every provisional sum and prime cost item in a renovation contract. Ask the builder whether the allowance is realistic for what you have discussed. Underestimated provisional sums are a common source of variation disputes in renovation projects.
Deposits
For residential building work in most Australian states, the maximum deposit a builder can legally request is ten percent of the contract value. Be cautious of builders requesting deposits above this amount or requesting large upfront payments before work commences.
Managing an occupied home renovation
Renovating an occupied home - where you and your family continue living in the property during construction - requires specific planning and communication that a new build does not.
Before work commences, confirm with your builder:
- Which areas of the home will be inaccessible during construction and for how long
- How dust and debris will be contained and managed
- What hours work will be conducted - typically 7am to 5pm Monday to Friday, with restrictions on Saturdays and no work on Sundays or public holidays in most states
- How site security will be managed - particularly if trades are on site when you are not home
- How the builder will handle emergency situations such as a plumbing failure or structural discovery that requires immediate decisions
The relationship between the homeowner and builder is more intimate and more daily in a renovation than in a new build. Clear, agreed communication expectations at the start of the project reduce misunderstandings and disputes significantly. Refer to the BUILTLY guide on how to manage a builder during construction for a complete framework. Understanding the defects liability period that follows completion protects your interests after the renovation is finished.
Warning signs - when to walk away
- Requests a deposit exceeding ten percent of the contract value before work starts
- Unwilling to provide a written contract or proposes only a verbal agreement
- Cannot provide a current licence number or is evasive when asked to verify it
- Cannot provide references from recent comparable renovation projects
- Provides a quote significantly lower than all others without being able to explain why
- Pressures you to sign quickly or make a rushed decision
- Is vague about who will actually be on site managing the day to day work
- Cannot confirm home warranty insurance has been arranged
- Has no ABN or cannot provide proof of insurance on request
- Has significant unresolved complaints registered with the relevant state building authority
Frequently Asked Questions
How is choosing a renovation builder different to choosing a new home builder?
Renovation builders work within existing structures, often in occupied homes, with conditions that cannot be fully known until work begins. They need different skills to new build builders - the ability to work around existing services, sequence trades in confined spaces, manage unexpected discoveries and communicate daily with homeowners living in the property. Always ask specifically about renovation experience and request references from comparable projects, not just general building work.
How many quotes should I get for a renovation?
Get at least three written quotes from licensed builders for any renovation over $20,000. Ensure all quotes are based on the same detailed scope of works so they can be compared item by item. A significantly lower quote without explanation is not a bargain - it typically means the builder has excluded items that will reappear as variations once work commences.
What should be in a renovation building contract?
A renovation contract should include the full scope of works in detail, all materials and finishes specified or with realistic provisional sum allowances, a start date and completion date, a payment schedule tied to defined construction milestones, a clear variations clause, dispute resolution process, the builder's licence number and home warranty insurance details. Do not proceed with any builder who is unwilling to provide a written contract.
What licences does a renovation builder need in Australia?
Renovation builders must hold a current builder's licence in the state where they are working. In Queensland this is a QBCC licence. In New South Wales, a contractor licence under the Home Building Act. In Victoria, registration with the Building and Plumbing Commission (BPC). Verify the licence directly with the relevant state authority before engaging any builder - do not rely on what the builder tells you.
How much deposit can a renovation builder charge?
In most Australian states, the maximum deposit a builder can legally request for residential building work is ten percent of the contract value. Be cautious of any builder requesting a deposit above this amount or requesting large upfront payments before work has commenced. Excessive upfront payments are a common feature of renovation fraud and builder insolvency situations.
How BUILTLY helps
BUILTLY is building a record of completed Australian homes that credits the builder, designers and trades behind each one.