New Home Regrets in Australia: The Most Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Last updated: October 2026

Building a new home is one of the most significant decisions an Australian will ever make - financially, emotionally and practically. For most people it is a once-in-a-lifetime experience. And yet research consistently shows that a significant proportion of Australian homeowners who build a new home emerge from the process with at least one regret - sometimes many.

A 2025 study found that 34 percent of Australian renovators and new home builders reported dissatisfaction with some aspect of their project outcome. The regrets range from relatively minor - a tap finish that dates quickly, a room orientation that could have been better - to genuinely significant - a builder relationship that broke down, a contract that allowed cost blowouts to accumulate unchecked, a site that was more expensive to build on than the original quote suggested.

What is striking about new home regrets in Australia is how consistent they are. The same themes emerge again and again - not because building is inherently a process that produces regret, but because the same avoidable mistakes are made repeatedly by homeowners who did not know what to watch for before they committed.

This guide documents the most common new home regrets reported by Australian homeowners - covering design decisions, builder selection, contracts, costs, construction management and the finished product - and explains specifically what you can do at each stage to avoid them.

Why New Home Regrets Are So Common in Australia

Understanding why new home regrets are so common helps frame what can be done to avoid them.

The information asymmetry problem - Building a new home involves engaging with a complex industry - builders, architects, engineers, certifiers, council planners, subcontractors and specialist trades - that most homeowners encounter for the first time. The people on the other side of the table are professionals who do this every day. The homeowner is making the largest financial decision of their life with limited experience and limited time to develop expertise. This asymmetry produces mistakes that experienced industry participants would never make themselves.

The decision fatigue problem - Building a new home involves hundreds of decisions - site selection, design brief, builder selection, contract negotiation, material selections, prime cost items, provisional sums, variations, progress payments and practical completion. Decision fatigue is real - the quality of decisions made late in a long process is consistently lower than decisions made early. Homeowners who make excellent decisions at the start of a project sometimes make poor decisions under time pressure at the end.

The optimism bias problem - Homeowners consistently underestimate how long their project will take, how much it will cost and how difficult the process will be. Optimism bias - the well-documented human tendency to believe our own outcomes will be better than average - produces budgets that are too tight, timelines that are too short and contingencies that are inadequate.

The once-in-a-lifetime problem - Unlike a builder or developer who builds dozens of homes, a homeowner typically builds once. There is no opportunity to apply the lessons of the first build to the second. Every mistake is a first mistake. This is precisely why guides like this one - which aggregate the experience of many homeowners into a single reference - have genuine value.

Regret 1 - Choosing the Wrong Builder

The single most consistent source of new home regret in Australia is choosing the wrong builder. Every other aspect of the new home experience - design, costs, construction quality, programme - is filtered through the builder relationship. A great builder can manage a complex project through challenges, communicate proactively and deliver a quality outcome even when things go wrong. A poor builder can turn a straightforward project into a years-long ordeal.

"We chose the builder with the lowest quote and spent the next two years regretting it - constant variations, poor communication, defects at every stage and a practical completion that was eighteen months late."

Why It Happens

Price is the most visible differentiator between builder quotes. It is easy to compare. It is also the most misleading differentiator - because the lowest quote is frequently the least accurate representation of what the project will actually cost. Builders who win work on price often do so by setting provisional sums too low, under-allowing for site conditions and planning to recover margin through variations.

How to Avoid It

Treat builder selection as the most important decision of the entire project - more important than the design, the finishes or the site. Invest time in the selection process before committing. Verify licences, check references from past clients, review completed projects and assess financial stability. Never choose a builder on price alone. For a comprehensive framework refer to the BUILTLY guide on How to Vet a Builder in Australia: A Complete Due Diligence Checklist.

BUILTLY is building a record of completed Australian homes that credits the builder, designers and trades behind each one.

Regret 2 - Not Understanding the Contract Before Signing

The building contract is the legal foundation of the entire project - and yet most homeowners sign it without fully understanding what it says. This is one of the most consequential and most common new home regrets in Australia.

"I signed the contract without reading it properly and only discovered what provisional sums were when the first one came back $40,000 over the allowance. By then it was too late."

Why It Happens

Building contracts are long, complex documents written in legal and technical language. Most homeowners are not lawyers. The contract is typically presented at a point in the process when the homeowner is excited and eager to proceed - a psychologically poor moment for careful scrutiny of unfavourable terms.

How to Avoid It

Read the contract in full before signing - every page, every schedule, every attachment. Pay particular attention to the provisional sum schedule and the prime cost item schedule - these two sections contain the majority of the cost uncertainty in most residential building contracts. Understand the variation procedure - how variations are initiated, how they are priced and how they are approved.

Consider engaging a solicitor with construction law experience to review the contract before signing. The cost - typically $500 to $2,000 - is modest relative to the financial exposure of an unfavourable contract on a major construction project.

BUILTLY is building a record of completed Australian homes that credits the builder, designers and trades behind each one.

Regret 3 - Underestimating the True Cost

Budget blowouts are one of the most universally shared new home experiences in Australia. Research consistently shows that more than 60 percent of Australian homeowners who build a new home spend more than they originally planned - typically 20 to 30 percent more.

"The builder quoted $850,000. We ended up spending $1.2 million. The provisional sums, the variations, the site costs - none of it was in the original number in the way we understood it."

Why It Happens

The headline contract price quoted by a builder typically does not represent the full cost of completing the project. Provisional sums are allowances for work that cannot be fully priced - and they frequently exceed the allowance. Prime cost items are allowances for products that have not been selected - and homeowners consistently choose products above the allowance. Site costs - earthworks, rock removal, service connections - are often significantly higher than the provisional sum allowance.

Add to this client-requested variations, landscaping costs that are almost never included in the builder's price and the cost of temporary accommodation during construction and the true cost of building a new home is almost always substantially higher than the contract price.

How to Avoid It

Build your budget from the true total project cost - not the builder's contract price. The total project cost includes:

  • Contract price including all prime cost item allowances
  • A realistic contingency on all provisional sums - add 30 to 40 percent to the total PS allowances
  • Landscaping - typically $30,000 to $150,000 on a quality project - almost never included in the builder's price
  • Temporary accommodation and storage during construction
  • Architect and consultant fees if not included in the contract
  • Council fees, infrastructure charges and connection costs
  • Furniture, window furnishings and appliances not included in the contract
  • A general contingency of 10 to 15 percent on the total project cost

For more detail on understanding and managing construction costs refer to the BUILTLY guide on How Much Does It Cost to Build a House in Australia? For a complete budgeting framework that covers all eight cost categories refer to the BUILTLY guide on Renovation Budget Australia.

Regret 4 - Getting the Orientation Wrong

Orientation - the direction a home faces relative to the sun - is one of the most consequential decisions in residential design and one of the most regretted. Unlike a tapware finish that can be replaced or a layout that can be modified, orientation is permanent. Once the home is built the orientation cannot be changed.

"Our main living areas face west. In summer the afternoon sun makes the living room uninhabitable without air conditioning running constantly. I wish we had understood passive solar design before we briefed the architect."

Why It Happens

Homeowners who are not familiar with passive solar design principles trust their architect or builder to handle orientation correctly - and in many cases the professional does not prioritise it either. Volume builders in particular frequently design to a standard floor plan that may not be optimally oriented for the specific site.

How to Avoid It

Understand the basics of passive solar design before briefing your designer. In most of Australia - including the Gold Coast, Brisbane, Sydney and Melbourne - the optimal orientation places the main living areas to the north, capturing winter sun for warmth and allowing summer sun to be shaded by appropriate roof overhangs. West-facing living areas should be avoided or heavily shaded. Bedrooms are better positioned to the east - capturing morning light without afternoon heat.

Ask your architect specifically how the proposed design responds to the orientation of the site. If the answer is vague or the design appears to have been applied to the site without consideration of its specific orientation push for a redesign. The cost of getting orientation right at design stage is zero. The cost of living in a poorly oriented home for decades is enormous - both in energy costs and in comfort.

For more detail on passive design and energy efficiency refer to the BUILTLY guide on Building a Passive House in Australia: Costs, Design and Complete Guide. For details on the mandatory 7-star NatHERS requirement for new homes refer to the BUILTLY guide on NatHERS Rating Australia: What It Is, How It Works and How to Improve Your Score.

Regret 5 - Not Building in Enough Storage

Storage is the most consistently underestimated element of residential design in Australia - and insufficient storage is one of the most frequently cited new home regrets.

"The house looks beautiful but there is nowhere to put anything. We have no linen cupboard, no pantry to speak of, no storage in the garage and the wardrobes are too small. I would give up a bedroom for more storage."

Why It Happens

Storage is invisible on a floor plan - it occupies space that could otherwise be allocated to a room, a corridor or a feature. Designers and homeowners both tend to focus on the rooms that are photographed and visited - kitchens, bathrooms, living spaces - at the expense of the unglamorous but essential storage infrastructure of a functional home.

How to Avoid It

Walk through your current home and document where everything is stored - every linen item, every cleaning product, every piece of sports equipment, every tool, every seasonal item. Then confirm that the proposed design has a designated storage location for every category. Specific items to check:

  • Linen cupboard - large enough for all linen including spare sets
  • Pantry - walk-in pantry if budget allows, with enough depth and shelving for your household
  • Broom cupboard or cleaning storage - often entirely omitted from standard designs
  • Garage storage - built-in storage wall or overhead storage system
  • Bedroom wardrobes - confirm dimensions allow for hanging, folding and shoe storage
  • Entry storage - coat hooks, shoe storage, bag storage for a family with children
  • Under-stair storage where applicable

A useful rule of thumb - whatever storage the design includes, add 20 percent more. You will never regret having more storage. You will absolutely regret having less.

Regret 6 - Making Too Many Changes During Construction

Variations - changes to the agreed scope made after the contract is signed and construction has commenced - are one of the most expensive and most regretted aspects of building a new home. Every variation costs money, almost always more than the homeowner expects, and frequently delays the project.

"I kept changing things during construction because I saw things I wanted to improve as the house went up. By the end I had spent $85,000 in variations and added four months to the programme. If I had finalised everything before we started it would have cost a fraction of that."

Why It Happens

It is genuinely difficult to fully visualise a completed home from drawings and specifications. Homeowners make selections before construction that they later change when they see the physical reality of the space. Decisions that seemed clear on paper look different in three dimensions.

How to Avoid It

The most powerful prevention is to finalise every decision before construction commences. Every selection that remains unmade at contract signing is a future variation waiting to happen. Work through the complete selection schedule - every tile, every tapware item, every appliance, every light fitting, every door handle - before signing the contract.

For decisions that are genuinely difficult to make from drawings consider engaging an interior designer early in the process - before the design is finalised - to help with selections. The cost of an interior designer is almost always recovered in the variations that are avoided.

Once construction commences treat the agreed design as fixed. Every variation request should be assessed against the question - is this genuinely necessary or is it a preference that I wish I had resolved before construction started? For more detail on managing variations refer to the BUILTLY guide on How to Manage a Builder During Construction.

Regret 7 - Choosing Trendy Finishes That Dated Quickly

Design trends in residential interiors move fast - and finishes that feel current at the time a home is built can feel dated within five to ten years. The permanent finishes of a home - tiles, flooring, cabinetry, tapware - are expensive and disruptive to change.

"We put in black tapware everywhere because it was everywhere at the time. Within three years it looked dated. The kitchen tiles were the same - we followed a trend and now they look like a specific year."

Why It Happens

Design media - Instagram, Pinterest, Houzz, magazines - constantly promotes the latest trends. Homeowners making selections during a build are immersed in this content. It is natural to want a home that looks current and aspirational at the time of building.

How to Avoid It

Apply a simple test to every permanent finish decision - has this material or finish been used in quality Australian homes for at least fifteen to twenty years, or did it appear in the last three to five years? Materials and finishes with genuine longevity - natural timber, natural stone, white or off-white walls, brushed nickel or chrome tapware, classic subway tile - have demonstrated staying power precisely because they are not trend-driven.

Reserve trend-driven choices for elements that are cheap and easy to change - paint colours, soft furnishings, artwork, plants. These can be updated as trends evolve without significant cost or disruption.

A useful question to ask your designer or interior designer - "Will this still look appropriate in twenty years?" If the answer is uncertain or qualified the finish may be trend-driven rather than timeless.

Regret 8 - Not Visiting the Site Often Enough During Construction

Many homeowners are too hands-off during construction - visiting the site infrequently and trusting the builder to manage quality without active engagement. Defects identified during construction are significantly cheaper and easier to rectify than defects discovered after practical completion.

"We trusted the builder completely and rarely visited the site. When we did the final walkthrough there were so many defects - things that would have been so easy to fix earlier. Some of them are still not fixed two years later."

Why It Happens

Many homeowners feel uncomfortable visiting the site frequently - they do not want to appear to distrust the builder or to micromanage. Others simply do not know what to look for. The result is that quality issues accumulate undetected until practical completion when they are much more difficult to address.

How to Avoid It

Establish a regular structured site visit schedule - fortnightly at minimum - at an agreed time with the builder. During each visit walk the entire site systematically and photograph everything. Learn what to check at each construction stage - waterproofing in wet areas before tiling, framing before linings, structural connections before they are concealed.

Consider engaging an independent building inspector to carry out inspections at key stages - slab, frame, lock-up and practical completion. The cost is modest relative to the value of the project and the potential cost of undetected defects. For comprehensive guidance refer to the BUILTLY guide on How to Manage a Builder During Construction.

Regret 9 - Neglecting Outdoor Spaces Until the Budget Was Exhausted

The outdoor spaces of a new home - landscaping, decking, pool, fencing, driveway - are almost never included in the builder's contract price. They are consistently the last element of a new home project to be funded and consistently the most budget-squeezed. Many homeowners move into a beautiful new home surrounded by bare dirt, temporary fencing and an unfinished driveway - and live that way for years.

"We spent everything on the house itself and had nothing left for the garden. We lived in bare dirt for three years. The outdoor spaces are what we see every day and they were an afterthought."

Why It Happens

Homeowners budget for the builder's contract price and underestimate or entirely omit the cost of the outdoor works that bring the property to a genuinely finished state. Landscaping in particular is seen as discretionary - something that can be deferred until after settlement. In practice deferral often means the outdoor spaces remain unfinished for years.

How to Avoid It

Include realistic landscaping and outdoor works costs in your total project budget from the very beginning - before you commit to the building contract price. A quality landscaping package for a new home typically costs $30,000 to $150,000 depending on the site, the scope and the specification level. Fencing, driveway, paths, turf, planting, retaining walls and outdoor entertaining areas all need to be funded from the total project budget. For a comprehensive guide to fencing types and costs refer to the BUILTLY guide on Fencing Cost Australia. For driveway material options and pricing refer to Driveway Cost Australia.

If the total project budget - including outdoor works - is not achievable consider reducing the specification of the house rather than eliminating the outdoor works entirely. A slightly smaller or less specified house with finished outdoor spaces is a more liveable outcome than a highly specified house surrounded by bare earth.

Regret 10 - Not Documenting the Completed Project

This is the regret that most homeowners do not know they have until years after the build - when they need information about the construction and cannot find it. What materials were used in the bathroom waterproofing? Where are the services runs? What is the specification of the structural engineer's design? What are the warranty documents for the major appliances and equipment?

"When we had a leak in the bathroom six years later we had no idea what waterproofing system had been used or who the waterproofing contractor was. We had no as-built drawings, no building handover package, no records of who built what. It cost us a fortune to diagnose and repair."

Why It Happens

Most builders provide a basic handover package at practical completion - keys, warranties for major items, operation manuals for equipment. This is rarely a comprehensive record of the construction. Homeowners do not know what they should ask for and builders do not volunteer what they are not required to provide.

How to Avoid It

Request a comprehensive building handover package from your builder at practical completion. This should include as-built drawings, all structural and engineering documentation, waterproofing certificates, energy efficiency certificates, all equipment warranties and operation manuals, a complete list of all materials and finishes used with supplier information, subcontractor contact details and certificate of occupancy documentation.

BUILTLY is building a record of completed Australian homes that credits the builder, designers and trades behind each one.

BUILTLY is building a record of completed Australian homes that credits the builder, designers and trades behind each one.

Regret 11 - Choosing a Site Without Understanding Its True Cost

The site is the foundation of every new home project - and site costs are the most variable, most underestimated and most regretted element of the total project budget. A site that appears affordable at purchase can become very expensive once the full cost of preparing it for construction is understood.

"We bought a sloped block because it was cheaper than flat land and we loved the view. The site costs were $180,000 more than the builder's provisional sum allowance. We would never have bought that block if we had understood what it would actually cost to build on."

Why It Happens

Site costs - earthworks, rock removal, retaining walls, service connections, drainage - are almost always included in the building contract as provisional sums based on limited information. The true site cost cannot be known with certainty until construction commences and the builder encounters actual site conditions. On challenging sites - sloped blocks, sites with fill, sites with poor soil or rock - the variation from allowance to actual can be very large.

How to Avoid It

Invest in site investigation before purchasing or before contracting. A geotechnical investigation - soil testing to confirm bearing capacity, soil type and depth to rock - costs $1,500 to $5,000 and provides the information required to assess site costs realistically before committing. A contour survey provides accurate topographic data that allows earthworks costs to be estimated much more accurately.

Research the site's history - was it previously filled? Is it in an area known for rock? Are there known drainage issues? Talk to neighbours and local builders who have worked in the area.

For more detail on site selection and due diligence refer to the BUILTLY guides on Development Site Due Diligence in Australia and Building on a Sloped Block in Australia.

Regret 12 - Rushing Practical Completion

Practical completion - the moment the keys are handed over and the homeowner takes possession of the new home - is a milestone that most homeowners approach with enormous excitement and urgency. After months or years of waiting, the temptation to accept practical completion even when the building is not genuinely complete is powerful. Many homeowners come to regret this decision.

"We were so desperate to move in that we accepted practical completion even though there were dozens of defects on the list. Once we were in and the final payment was made the builder's responsiveness dropped to almost zero. Half the defects were never fixed."

Why It Happens

The builder's financial incentive to rectify defects is highest before the final payment is released. Once the homeowner has taken possession and released the final payment the builder's leverage disappears. Builders who are slow to rectify defects become even slower once the contract is financially complete.

How to Avoid It

Never accept practical completion with an unresolved defects list that you are not confident will be addressed. The practical completion inspection - the formal walkthrough before handover - is your most important protection. Conduct it thoroughly and document every defect in writing with photographs.

Understand that you are entitled to withhold acceptance of practical completion until genuine practical completion is achieved - the building is complete in all material respects and fit for occupation. Do not allow yourself to be pressured into accepting completion with significant unresolved defects.

Retain a portion of the final payment - or use the defects liability period provisions in your contract - to maintain leverage for defect rectification after you move in.

For comprehensive guidance refer to the BUILTLY guide on Practical Completion in Australia: A Complete Guide for Homeowners.

The Common Thread - What Every Regret Has in Common

Reading through these twelve most common new home regrets a pattern emerges. Almost every one of them traces back to one of three root causes:

Insufficient information at a critical decision point

BUILTLY is building a record of completed Australian homes that credits the builder, designers and trades behind each one.

Insufficient time spent on selection and planning before committing

The decisions that most commonly produce regret are the ones made too quickly - under time pressure, under social pressure from a builder keen to sign, or under the influence of excitement and optimism bias. Slowing down at the selection and planning stage is the single most effective way to reduce new home regrets.

Insufficient engagement during construction

Homeowners who are actively engaged during construction - visiting the site regularly, communicating proactively, documenting everything - consistently report better outcomes than homeowners who trust the process without active oversight.

The good news is that none of these regrets are inevitable. Every one of them can be avoided by a homeowner who is well informed, well prepared and actively engaged throughout the project.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most common regret when building a new home in Australia?

Research consistently identifies choosing the wrong builder as the most impactful regret - because the builder relationship affects every other aspect of the project outcome. Other consistently cited regrets include insufficient storage, poor room orientation, budget blowouts from provisional sums and variations, and rushing practical completion before defects are rectified. The common theme across most regrets is insufficient information or insufficient time spent on critical decisions before committing.

How can I avoid budget blowouts when building a new home in Australia?

The most effective approach is to build your total project budget from the true all-in cost - not just the builder's contract price. Add a realistic contingency to all provisional sums - at least 30 to 40 percent - include landscaping and outdoor works costs from the beginning and maintain a general project contingency of 10 to 15 percent. Have a quantity surveyor independently review the provisional sum allowances in the contract before signing. Research comparable project costs for similar homes on similar sites in your area.

How do I choose the right builder to avoid regrets?

Treat builder selection as the most important decision of the entire project. Verify the builder's licence and insurance. Check references from at least three past clients who have completed projects of comparable type and scale - and call them rather than relying on written testimonials. Visit a completed project in person. Review the builder's financial stability - insolvency is a major risk in the Australian construction industry. Assess the quality of the builder's communication during the tender process - builders who communicate poorly before they are engaged almost never improve once the contract is signed.

What should I do if I discover defects after moving into my new home?

Document all defects in writing with photographs as soon as they are discovered. Notify the builder in writing - email - as soon as possible. Most residential building contracts include a defects liability period - typically thirteen weeks to twelve months after practical completion - during which the builder is required to rectify defects at no cost to the homeowner. Defects notified during this period must be addressed. If the builder fails to respond to formal defect notifications seek legal advice and consider lodging a complaint with the relevant state building authority.

Is it normal to have regrets after building a new home in Australia?

Regrets of some kind are genuinely common - research suggests around one in three Australian homeowners who build report some dissatisfaction with their project outcome. However the nature and severity of regrets varies enormously. Minor aesthetic regrets - a finish choice that dated, a room size that could have been slightly larger - are normal and manageable. Major regrets - a builder relationship that broke down, a significant cost overrun, a defect that was never rectified - are less common but far more consequential. Most major regrets are avoidable with thorough preparation, careful builder selection and active engagement throughout the construction process.